MBChB, MRCS, FRCS (Trauma & Orth)
29 years of experience
Sutton Coldfield, B74 3UP
(+1 more)
33 connections in healthcare
Skill endorsed
by Mr Mark Hamlet, Dr Gurjit Bhogal and 6 other professionals
29 years of experience
Sutton Coldfield, B74 3UP
(+1 more)
33 connections in healthcare
Skill endorsed
by Mr Mark Hamlet, Dr Gurjit Bhogal and 6 other professionals
Areas of expertise
Contact
Book
Mr James Arbuthnot is a Consultant Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgeon with a specialist focus on knee surgery. He has been practising as a consultant since 2008 and dedicates his clinical practice exclusively to the diagnosis and treatment of knee conditions.
Mr Arbuthnot treats both younger and older patients, managing sports-related injuries such as ligament tears, cartilage injuries and fractures, as well as degenerative conditions including osteoarthritis of the knee. He has a particular interest in the treatment of early arthritis, where emerging surgical and non-surgical techniques can help reduce pain, preserve joint function and delay the need for joint replacement.
He performs a high volume of knee procedures each year, including total and partial knee replacements and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructions. On average, he carries out between 75 and 100 knee replacements annually, along with 70 to 75 ACL reconstructions. He also manages complex cases requiring revision knee replacement surgery.
Mr Arbuthnot also offers robotic-arm assisted joint replacement surgery using the Mako system, which allows highly precise planning and placement of knee implants. These procedures are available at Spire Little Aston Hospital and Spire Parkway Hospital.
He works as a surgical partner at the Midland Knee Clinic, a specialist centre dedicated to the treatment of knee injuries and conditions. The clinic provides both surgical and non-surgical care for patients locally in the Midlands as well as nationally and internationally, with outpatient and surgical services based in Solihull and Sutton Coldfield. Through his focused approach and extensive experience, Mr Arbuthnot aims to deliver optimal outcomes and long-term function for patients with knee problems.
Click the bar to read reviews or skill endorsements
General Medical Council
No. 4449340
University of Liverpool
Medicine
Graduated 1997
Member of the Royal College of Surgeons (Eng) 2001
Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons (Eng) (Tr. and Orth) 2008
Masters in Sports (Football Medicine) - University of Bath 2025 to present
New appointment
£200Follow-up appointment
£150Little Aston Hall Drive, Sutton Coldfield, United Kingdom, B74 3UP
1 Damson Parkway, Solihull, Birmingham, United Kingdom, B91 2PP
Areas of expertise
Contact
Book
This summary was created by AI based on recent reviews
Mr James Arbuthnot is excellent and clear with patients, ensuring they feel listened to. He gives clear information on various knee surgeries, leading to successful outcomes like ACL reconstruction. Patients regain confidence and return to normal daily activities without pain. His practice focuses on knee pain, knee arthritis, total knee replacement, and knee arthroscopy.
Operation a total success. Life changing result, wish I’d have had it done years ago!
I came to Mr Arbuthnot due to instability in my knee and pain and he was able to quickly assess the problem and promptly arranged surgery to correct the issue. Very professional and a great surgeon
Appointments always on time and James is always very pleasant, informative and detailed.
Mr Arbuthnot's explanation of the state of my arthritic knee together with the pain I was experiencing convinced me that a knee replacement wasn't really optional but totally necessary as without an operation I would not be able to walk. On operation day he explained what would happen and the procedures that would take place before the operation. After the operation Mr Arbuthnot together with the anaesthetist explained why the procedure was changed
Mr Arbuthnot replaced my knee in May 2026, The whole experience was trouble free, he is lovely to deal with and would recommend .
Hospital stay very short but staff extremely considerate. Follow ups efficienr and well explainef
Surgery procedure went well, I received excellent care with every step of my hospital visit/stay being explained and with appropriate reassurance. Post surgical care was also top quality. The only problem I experienced was excessive blistering all around the plaster placed over my wound, this appeared to me to be caused by an allergic reaction to the plaster, the surgeon felt there could be other causes. Anyway I received plenty of post operative care including physio and nursing care (for my blistering around my wound - which was resolved over a few weeks). All in all five stars from me thank you. The surgery proceeded smoothly, and I received excellent care; each stage of my hospital stay was explained with suitable reassurance. Post-surgical attention was equally high quality. The sole issue was extensive blistering around the plaster over my wound, which seemed to stem from an allergic reaction, though the surgeon suggested alternative causes. I nonetheless received ample post-operative support, including physiotherapy and nursing care for the blistering, which settled over several weeks. Overall, I give five stars—thank you.
The pre-operative online information was excellent, although some of the postal correspondence was duplicated. All appointments, consultations and scans were well organised, and staff were welcoming, informative and professional throughout. The operation and immediate post-operative care were very good, with everything clearly explained. However, the following morning felt less organised, and it was concerning to hear staff say they were overstretched. I also experienced some issues with pulse-rate monitoring and post-operative nausea. I mentioned that this could potentially be linked to my use of Mounjaro, but I felt this concern was not fully considered. The discharge process was smooth, the post-operative physiotherapy was excellent, and the online communications worked very well. The final consultation provided a valuable opportunity to discuss my recovery and any concerns. Overall, this was a very positive experience, and I am grateful for the high standard of care I received. My comments are intended as constructive feedback to help improve an otherwise excellent experience
Had knee replacement. He gave me every opportunity using other ways before I had the operation to help me. Eventually had the surgery and consultant was professional from start to finish. Explained everything to me. Operation went brilliantly
I had a great experience as expected and found Mr Arbuthnot to be very good at telling you what was happening before and after the operation. He has a great reputation which I can confirm is correct and would not hesitate to recommend him to anyone getting knee surgery.
An excellent and approachable knee surgeon
03 Aug 2026
Mr Mark Hamlet
Orthopaedic SurgeonFantastic opinion on knees. I highly recommend.
08 Jul 2026
Dr Gurjit Bhogal
Sport & Exercise Medicine DoctorVery pleasant , knowledgeable and sensible. Great communicator
25 May 2026
Mr Mark Simmons
ENT Surgeon
Dr Mary Gayed
Rheumatologist
Find out more on the Doctify Health hub for Mr James Arbuthnot's specialty, Orthopaedic Surgery.
What are Mr James Arbuthnot's reviews like?
Mr James Arbuthnot's overall patient rating is 4.92 out of 5 stars on Doctify. This is based on 118 reviews.
What languages does Mr James Arbuthnot speak?
Mr James Arbuthnot speaks English
Where is Mr James Arbuthnot located?
Mr James Arbuthnot primarily practices at Spire Little Aston Hospital, located at Little Aston Hall Drive, Sutton Coldfield, United Kingdom, B74 3UP
See more locations
What are Mr James Arbuthnot working hours?
Mr James Arbuthnot is working Monday (10:00 - 13:00, 15:30 - 20:00), Wednesday (15:30 - 20:00, 10:15 - 14:00), Thursday (18:00 - 20:00), Friday (17:30 - 20:00)
Find where Mr James Arbuthnot operates today
Does Mr James Arbuthnot accept new patients?
Mr James Arbuthnot generally accepts new patients.
Get in touch with this specialist to enquire as a new patient